Why Does Harrow the Ninth Contradict Gideon the Ninth? What Is Actually Happening Explained
Editorial image generated by the author. If you begin Tamsyn Muir's Harrow the Ninth shortly after finishing Gideon the Ninth , confusion quickly turns into suspicion. Why is Ortus suddenly Harrow's cavalier at Canaan House? Why does she remember events that plainly did not happen? Why has Gideon Nav—the protagonist of the previous novel—apparently vanished from history? And why is the Emperor's ancient Lyctor, whom the reader knows as Gideon the First, now being called Ortus the First? At some point a perfectly reasonable possibility occurs: did I misunderstand the first book? The answer is no. Harrow the Ninth is not quietly retconning Gideon the Ninth . The reader has been placed inside a version of reality that Harrow herself has made unreliable. The central fact that makes the novel intelligible is this: Harrow has deliberately altered her own brain so that she cannot properly remember, recognise or process Gideon Nav. She believes that making Gi...