When Nobody Knows How It Works Anymore: AI, Cognitive Offloading and Lost Expertise
Editorial image generated by the author. In 1958, Leonard Read published a peculiar little economics essay called I, Pencil . Its narrator was an ordinary wooden pencil, and its central boast was that no single person knew how to make it . That sounds, at first, remarkably like one of the anxieties now surrounding artificial intelligence. We increasingly rely on systems whose workings we do not fully understand while handing them tasks we once had to perform ourselves. Eventually, perhaps, we forget how. But I, Pencil was not a warning about lost knowledge. It was an argument for the enormous productive power of not knowing everything. The wood, graphite, lacquer, metal and machinery involved in making a pencil depend on different people possessing different pieces of knowledge. Nobody has to understand the entire process for the process to work. That makes the pencil a better starting point for thinking about AI than it first appears. The problem is not that arti...