Posts

Burnt Offerings Review: When the Monsters Become Caricatures

Image
Laurell K. Hamilton | Anita Blake, Vampire Hunter #7 | 1998 Laurell K. Hamilton's Burnt Offerings , the seventh Anita Blake novel, introduces some of the most powerful vampires the series has encountered. Unfortunately, many of them are also among the least interesting. The arrival of the Vampire Council brings ancient rivalries, disturbing supernatural abilities and an extraordinary amount of torture and humiliation. Yet the more thoroughly Hamilton establishes the Council's cruelty, the more predictable its members become. Anita herself is a more compelling problem. Her powers and loyalties are changing so rapidly that she is becoming part of the supernatural hierarchy she once confronted from the outside. The woman who divided the world into humans and monsters now finds herself protecting monsters, answering to them and exercising authority over them. Hamilton has plenty to say about how dangerous the Council is. I wish she were as interested in what Anita's growin...

Murderbot Season One Review: What the TV Adaptation Loses Inside Murderbot’s Head

Image
Promotional image: Murderbot Season One, Apple TV+. Used here for purposes of review and commentary. Murderbot looks remarkably easy to adapt until you ask where the story actually happens. Martha Wells gives us hostile planets, corporate conspiracies, combat machines and sudden violence, all convenient material for television. But the thing that makes The Murderbot Diaries distinctive is not any of those things. It is the running argument inside Murderbot’s head between what it claims to feel, what it actually feels, and what it does despite itself. Apple’s first season handles the visible parts of that story remarkably well. It looks excellent, Alexander Skarsgård is very good, the humour survives the change of medium, and turning Murderbot’s beloved soap opera The Rise and Fall of Sanctuary Moon into an actual show-within-the-show is inspired. Yet I finished the season with much the same suspicion I had before it began: Murderbot may be one of Martha Wells’s le...

How to Win Friends and Influence People by Dale Carnegie Review: Simple Advice, Difficult Habits

Image
I originally bought Dale Carnegie’s How to Win Friends and Influence People for my son, hoping it might help him develop some useful social skills. He never finished it. Having now read the book myself, I suspect I may have been the person who needed its advice more. Not because Carnegie reveals anything especially mysterious about human behaviour. Much of what he recommends is almost embarrassingly obvious: listen to people, take an interest in what matters to them, offer genuine appreciation and avoid unnecessary criticism. I already try to do several of these things, and the advice generally agrees with what I have learned from work and everyday life. Yet I also recognised how easily I abandon those principles when I am irritated, impatient or convinced that someone else is wrong. Cover image: How to Win Friends and Influence People by Dale Carnegie. Used for purposes of review and commentary. First published in 1936, the book grew out of Carnegie’s courses in public ...

Why Smart People Produce Stupid Systems: Incentives and Institutional Failure

Image
Editorial image generated by the author. It is one of the stranger features of institutional life: everyone can agree that a process is wasteful, everyone can complain about it, and yet the process survives. A report is prepared every month because it has always been prepared every month. Several people review it. Someone reconciles numbers that few decisions depend on. A manager signs off because removing the control would require taking responsibility for whatever might happen without it. Senior leadership periodically asks why the organisation is so bureaucratic. Then the next month's report is prepared. It is tempting to explain this as incompetence. Sometimes incompetence really is the problem. But many dysfunctional systems are staffed by capable people making decisions that are quite defensible from where they sit. The employee who refuses to prepare the report risks appearing careless. The manager who removes the control receives little credit if nothin...

Silver Borne by Patricia Briggs Review: A Turning Point for Mercy Thompson

Image
Mercy Thompson #5 | First published in 2010 Minor spoilers for earlier Mercy Thompson novels; major developments in Silver Borne are left undisclosed. I thought Silver Borne was where I stopped reading Patricia Briggs’ Mercy Thompson series the first time around. Having finished it again, I am no longer sure. I remember a different plot, possibly from a later book, or perhaps several stories that have merged together in my head. Much of this fifth novel felt unfamiliar, but it also reminded me how much the series has accumulated since Moon Called . Events that once seemed like individual adventures have become a history that the characters must live with. Samuel’s long struggle with his wolf is coming to a crisis, Mercy’s place in Adam’s pack remains contested, and a borrowed book left over from Iron Kissed brings her into conflict with the fae. These problems have been developing for several novels. Where Iron Kissed changed the emotional stakes of the series , Silver Borne ...

Who Is Nona in Nona the Ninth? Harrow, Alecto, Gideon and the Ending Explained

Image
Editorial image generated by the author. Tamsyn Muir begins Nona the Ninth with a problem that sounds simple enough: a young woman has woken up in somebody else's body and does not remember who she is. Unfortunately, this is The Locked Tomb . The body belongs to Harrowhark Nonagesimus. Harrow's body has previously contained Gideon Nav's soul. Harrow herself vanished somewhere during the ending of Harrow the Ninth . Gideon's corpse still exists elsewhere. And the woman in the Locked Tomb—the figure Harrow has seen and worshipped since childhood—has her own unexplained connection to everything that happened. Camilla, Palamedes and Pyrrha therefore spend months trying to determine whether the cheerful amnesiac calling herself Nona is Harrow, Gideon or something else entirely. The answer is that Nona is the amnesiac Alecto-presence inhabiting Harrow's body. Without Alecto's remembered identity, that presence spends roughly six months developin...

If LLMs Are a Dead End, Could They Still Accelerate AGI?

Image
François Chollet has made one of the sharper criticisms of the current artificial-intelligence boom. In a 2024 interview with Dwarkesh Patel , the creator of Keras and ARC-AGI, and co-founder of the ARC Prize, argued that OpenAI had effectively set progress toward artificial general intelligence back by five to ten years. Chollet gave two reasons. First, he argued that frontier AI research had become much less open, with leading laboratories publishing fewer of the technical details that previously allowed ideas to spread across the research community. Second, he believed that the success of large language models had caused them to “suck the oxygen out of the room”: money, compute and researchers were flowing toward an approach he regarded as an off-ramp rather than a route to AGI. The first criticism is mainly institutional. The second creates a stranger counterfactual. Suppose Chollet is right that scaling transformers never produces artificial general intelligence. It still does...