Reading for the Kids: Finding the Right Story at the Right Moment
Most of the reading I do for the children happens during the school year. Once summer arrives, routines dissolve and bedtime becomes more of a suggestion than a rule. During term time, however, reading is firmly embedded in the evening ritual.
These days, that ritual mainly involves the two youngest. The oldest reads independently now—something I had recently begun to reflect on when writing about the difference between reading together and learning to read alone.
Finding one book that would genuinely work for all three children would be a Herculean task. It is difficult enough to find something that both a soon-to-be-six-year-old and a nine-year-old will enjoy.
Reading aloud is therefore less a matter of selecting the best children’s books than of matching a particular story to particular listeners. Age matters, but so do mood, attention, tiredness and the complicated politics of bedtime.
Reading for Two Different Listeners
There is the constant stream of questions. Some are about unfamiliar words, which is good and something I actively want to encourage, even when it interrupts the rhythm of the story. Others emerge from drifting attention or an overwhelming need to comment on absolutely everything.
It can be frustrating, but it is also part of the experience. Reading aloud is not a performance delivered to a silent audience. It is part story, part conversation and, on difficult evenings, part negotiation.
Following the plot becomes harder when reading for two very different listeners. One has a tendency to fall asleep within five seconds. The other can produce an impressive list of reasons why sleep is impossible tonight.
Some evenings, we barely make it through a couple of pages. On others, we continue despite one child clearly being asleep because the other is still listening intently. Given that, I can understand why the story may occasionally feel difficult for them to follow. One child misses pages through sleep; the other hears them between questions and arguments about whether the chapter can possibly end there.
I remember that listening could also be harder for me than reading independently. I have written elsewhere about how being read to shaped my own reading life, but attention was never perfectly obedient.
A sentence could spark some private chain of thought, and suddenly the story had continued without me. The same thing happened when I was reading alone: I would reach the bottom of a page and realise that my eyes had kept moving while my imagination had wandered somewhere else.
Perhaps some interruptions are not evidence that a story has failed to hold a child’s attention. They may be evidence that it has given the imagination something else to do.
Finding the Next Book
We recently finished Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets. That was my third time through the book, but the first reread undertaken primarily for the benefit of the youngest.
She has remained somewhat lukewarm about Harry Potter, so we moved on to Charlie and the Chocolate Factory in the hope of finding something that suited her better.
They had already seen Wonka, though not either film adaptation of Charlie and the Chocolate Factory. We had also read Matilda and Boy: Tales of Childhood, and they had seen The Wonderful Story of Henry Sugar. Roald Dahl therefore seemed like a reasonably safe choice.
So far, the choice seems to be working, even though the book is noticeably bleaker than I remembered. Charlie’s poverty and hunger are not merely background details. They create the pressure under which his decency is tested.
Children living amid poverty, neglect and grotesquely unfair circumstances—and somehow triumphing anyway—recur throughout Dahl’s work. His cruelty is broad, comic and rarely subtle, but the misery beneath it can be quite real. I can see why that combination continues to resonate with children.
We will probably finish Charlie and the Chocolate Factory before the school holidays. After that, the plan is to return to Astrid Lindgren in January.
Emil was a clear success when we read it earlier, and we have dipped into Pippi Longstocking occasionally with reasonable results. Revisiting Pippi seems promising. I am also considering introducing them to Just William, although I am less certain how well its humour and setting will travel across generations.
That uncertainty is unavoidable. A book can be excellent, age-appropriate and beloved by generations of readers, yet still arrive at the wrong moment for the children listening to it.
The real challenge is not building a perfect list. It is keeping the ritual alive through the questions, the interruptions, the sleeping child and the one who insists that sleep remains medically impossible.
When the choice works, the effort is still very much worthwhile. The right book is not simply the right book. It is the right book for these listeners, on this particular night.
Comments
Post a Comment