Why Does Harrow the Ninth Contradict Gideon the Ninth? What Is Actually Happening Explained
If you begin Tamsyn Muir's Harrow the Ninth shortly after finishing Gideon the Ninth, confusion quickly turns into suspicion. Why is Ortus suddenly Harrow's cavalier at Canaan House? Why does she remember events that plainly did not happen? Why has Gideon Nav—the protagonist of the previous novel—apparently vanished from history? And why is the Emperor's ancient Lyctor, whom the reader knows as Gideon the First, now being called Ortus the First?
At some point a perfectly reasonable possibility occurs: did I misunderstand the first book? The answer is no. Harrow the Ninth is not quietly retconning Gideon the Ninth. The reader has been placed inside a version of reality that Harrow herself has made unreliable.
The central fact that makes the novel intelligible is this: Harrow has deliberately altered her own brain so that she cannot properly remember, recognise or process Gideon Nav. She believes that making Gideon inaccessible to herself is the only way to prevent Gideon's soul from being completely consumed by the Lyctoral process. Almost everything that feels wrong in Harrow the Ninth grows out of that decision.
There is a second complication. The apparent Canaan House flashbacks are not merely false memories. Harrow's rewritten version of the past supplies the script for a bubble in the River, where the souls of people who actually died at Canaan House begin to act independently of her. The novel is therefore running two mysteries at once: what Harrow did to her own mind, and what that damaged mind has subsequently created.
Major spoilers for Gideon the Ninth and Harrow the Ninth follow.
What Did Harrow Do to Her Own Mind?
The ending of Gideon the Ninth still happened. Gideon Nav was Harrow's cavalier at Canaan House. They undertook the Lyctoral trials together and discovered that becoming a Lyctor appeared to require a necromancer to incorporate the soul of a cavalier, gaining extraordinary power at the cost of the cavalier's life.
When Cytherea revealed herself and the surviving characters were trapped in an apparently hopeless fight, Gideon made the choice for Harrow. She threw herself onto the iron spikes surrounding them, dying so that Harrow could use her soul and become powerful enough to defeat Cytherea. Harrow did so—but she did not accept that Gideon's disappearance had to be permanent.
Before most of the events narrated in Harrow the Ninth, Harrow recruits Ianthe Tridentarius to help her perform an extraordinary act of self-surgery. She alters her own brain so that Gideon becomes neurologically inaccessible. This is more radical than ordinary amnesia. Harrow is not simply trying to forget someone whose death she cannot bear; she is attempting to make her own mind incapable of recognising Gideon at all, because she believes that doing so will stop Gideon's soul from being fully absorbed into her own.
She effectively creates an internal censorship mechanism. The name "Gideon" becomes particularly dangerous, and Harrow's altered mind substitutes Ortus for it. That produces one of the novel's earliest and most useful clues: the ancient Lyctor whom everyone else knows as Gideon the First becomes, from Harrow's perspective, Ortus the First. The universe has not changed his name. Harrow has.
The same mechanism reaches backwards into her understanding of Canaan House. Gideon Nav can no longer occupy the place she actually occupied in Harrow's history, so somebody else has to stand where Gideon should be. Ortus Nigenad is the obvious replacement.
Why Does Ortus Replace Gideon at Canaan House?
Ortus really was supposed to be Harrow's cavalier before the events of Gideon the Ninth. He fled the Ninth House with his mother rather than accompany Harrow to Canaan House, leaving Gideon to take his place. Once Harrow has made Gideon mentally inaccessible, her reconstructed past therefore puts Ortus back into the role he was originally meant to occupy.
This is why the second novel seems to contradict the first so aggressively. We are shown events resembling those of Gideon the Ninth, except Gideon has disappeared and the consequences of that absence spread outward. Conversations happen differently. Relationships change. Characters appear in situations they never occupied. Harrow's past has been rebuilt around a missing person whose absence cannot itself be acknowledged.
But this is not a clean alternate history stored inside Harrow's memory. The reconstruction keeps developing cracks. People say things that do not fit. Ortus begins to sense that something is wrong. Characters refuse to behave like projections produced entirely by Harrow's imagination. The reason is that the Canaan House sequences are happening somewhere more complicated than memory.
The False Canaan House and the Sleeper
The third-person Canaan House chapters initially resemble distorted flashbacks, but Harrow has created a bubble in the River—a constructed pocket reality whose basic script comes from her altered version of the past. Within that space, however, several of the apparent characters are genuine spirits of the dead.
Abigail and Magnus Pent are there. Ortus is there. Marta Dyas and Protesilaus are there. Even Dulcinea Septimus—the real Dulcinea, rather than Cytherea impersonating her—can appear. As these ghosts gradually realise that the world around them is false, the distinction becomes important: Harrow may have constructed the stage, but she does not control all the actors.
Another presence has entered the bubble as well. The threatening figure known as the Sleeper is eventually revealed as Commander Wake, a leader of Blood of Eden and Gideon Nav's mother. Wake has persisted after death as a revenant and elsewhere succeeds in possessing Cytherea's corpse. Inside Harrow's River bubble, her presence turns the distorted Canaan House story into a literal supernatural conflict.
The apparent contradiction with Gideon the Ninth therefore operates on several levels. Harrow's altered brain has erased Gideon and rewritten her personal history around that absence. Her necromantic mind has given that false history form inside the River. Actual dead people inhabit the reconstruction, discover that it is wrong and begin resisting the script Harrow has unconsciously supplied.
Trying to read these chapters as straightforward flashbacks makes the novel considerably more confusing than it needs to be. They are not simply telling us what Harrow remembers. They are showing us what happens when a deliberately falsified memory becomes a world other minds can inhabit.
Why Is Harrow the Ninth Written in Second Person?
The narration provides another clue almost from the beginning. Much of Harrow's present-day story is told in the second person: you did this; you saw this; you thought this. At first it can look like an eccentric stylistic experiment. It is not.
The "you" exists because somebody is speaking to Harrow: Gideon.
Gideon's soul has not disappeared. Harrow's intervention has prevented her from being completely consumed, leaving Gideon present within Harrow even though Harrow herself cannot consciously recognise her. The narrator therefore knows things Harrow does not, notices details Harrow would not emphasise and occasionally reacts to people in ways that sound subtly wrong for Harrow but very right for Gideon.
When Harrow is catastrophically wounded and Gideon finally comes forward, the trick becomes obvious. The narrative voice suddenly becomes recognisably hers: irreverent, aggressive, emotional, physically attentive and completely unlike Harrow's usual manner of describing the world. Gideon begins controlling Harrow's body.
The second person was therefore not merely Tamsyn Muir choosing an unusual grammatical perspective. The grammar itself was evidence. Harrow believes herself to be alone inside her own consciousness, while the novel has been quietly demonstrating that she is not.
Harrow's plan has worked. Gideon survived—not cleanly, comfortably or in the form Harrow would have wanted, but she was not completely consumed. The tragedy is that Harrow cannot initially experience the success of her own plan: she mutilated her memory precisely so that the person she was trying to save would become inaccessible to her. The reader can recognise Gideon before Harrow can.
Gideon, the Body and Harrow's Divided Consciousness
Gideon's survival should not be confused with another presence Harrow repeatedly sees: the Body. Harrow has encountered the Body since long before Gideon's death. As a child, she broke into the Locked Tomb and saw the apparently dead or sleeping woman inside, an experience that became central to her religion, desires and sense of destiny.
The figure Harrow sees during Harrow the Ninth resembles the woman in the Tomb—Alecto—and is tied to that mystery and therefore to the Emperor's oldest secrets. The precise status of these appearances is deliberately not resolved by this novel. The distinction required to follow the story is simpler: Gideon is the consciousness preserved within Harrow, while the Body is associated with the woman Harrow found in the Locked Tomb. They are not competing explanations for the same presence.
This becomes increasingly important because the novel's larger plot keeps producing variations on the same problem: bodies and souls do not correspond as neatly as the accepted account of Lyctorhood suggests.
What Pyrrha Reveals About Lyctorhood
The clearest example is Gideon the First—the ancient Lyctor Harrow's altered brain calls Ortus the First. John has ordered him to force Harrow's broken Lyctorhood to resolve, with death as the alternative. He repeatedly attacks her in the hope that extreme danger will trigger the automatic abilities a complete Lyctor should possess.
Eventually Gideon the First dies, but his body does not become empty. Instead Pyrrha Dve appears.
Pyrrha was Gideon the First's cavalier and was supposedly consumed thousands of years earlier when he became a Lyctor. Yet a substantial part of her survived within him and could sometimes control his body. Her existence proves that incomplete cavalier absorption is not unique to Harrow, even if the exact mechanism is not necessarily the same as Gideon Nav's survival.
Harrow herself provides another variation. She possesses Lyctoral power but is conspicuously weaker and less functional than Ianthe or the ancient Lyctors. Her body does not heal or defend itself with the same automatic efficiency. To the others, something has gone wrong. From Harrow's perspective, the incompleteness is the point: she interrupted the process because Gideon's continued existence mattered more than complete access to Lyctoral power.
Her weakness is therefore evidence of Gideon's survival. The Lyctoral process Harrow discovered at Canaan House treats cavalier consumption as the price of becoming something greater. Harrow's answer, whether or not she ever phrases it this way, is that she would rather remain incomplete.
By the end of the novel, Pyrrha's survival and Harrow's intervention have destabilised the apparently simple formula of Lyctorhood. A cavalier does not always vanish cleanly. A soul may remain, take control or resist complete absorption. Then Mercymorn and Augustine discover that John's own relationship with Alecto does not appear to follow the model they used either.
What Did John Hide About Lyctorhood?
Gideon Nav turns out to be John's biological daughter, conceived as part of an elaborate Blood of Eden plan to obtain his genetic material and use it to break the blood wards protecting the Locked Tomb. When Gideon controls Harrow's body, her eyes provide Mercymorn and Augustine with a crucial piece of evidence.
Eye colour changes during Lyctoral fusion. What they see leads them to conclude that Alecto was John's cavalier and that John achieved a form of Lyctorhood that preserved her rather than consuming her in the manner of their own cavaliers. From their perspective, the implication is devastating: John allowed his original disciples to believe their cavaliers had to die despite possessing knowledge that suggested another outcome was possible.
That discovery breaks what remains of their loyalty. For ten thousand years Augustine and Mercymorn have lived with the deaths on which their immortality was built. Now they have reason to suspect that those sacrifices may not have been as inevitable as they believed.
The exact nature of John and Alecto's relationship is more complicated than the surviving Lyctors understand at this point, and later books add important information. Within Harrow the Ninth, however, what matters is their realisation that the story John gave them about Lyctorhood was incomplete and that he knew more than he told them.
Pyrrha makes the situation messier still. She and Gideon the First did not achieve whatever happened between John and Alecto, yet she survived anyway. Harrow and Gideon represent another incomplete arrangement. Lyctorhood no longer looks like one clean magical technology in which the cavalier dies and the necromancer simply inherits their power. It looks more like a family of unstable relationships between body, soul, identity and power.
Where Are Harrow and Gideon at the End?
While Gideon is controlling Harrow's body in the physical world, Harrow herself remains in the River. The Canaan House bubble collapses, the spirits who inhabited it move on, and Harrow finally remembers Gideon. She understands what she did and realises that Gideon is now active inside her body.
Returning presents the same danger Harrow mutilated herself to avoid: if she resumes control normally, the interrupted absorption of Gideon's soul may also resume. Harrow therefore does something characteristically extreme. She refuses to go back.
Instead she retreats into a representation of the Locked Tomb and lies down inside the coffin, where she finds objects associated with Gideon. The reversal is striking. The Locked Tomb once represented the inaccessible figure Harrow worshipped from a distance; now it becomes the place where Harrow makes herself inaccessible so that Gideon can continue to exist. After spending most of the novel unable to remember Gideon, Harrow's first major decision after recovering her memory is once again to remove herself from Gideon's way.
Gideon's position is less secure. She has been controlling Harrow's body, but the confrontation aboard the Mithraeum ends catastrophically when Augustine pulls the station into the River during his fight with John. Gideon and Pyrrha try to survive, and the novel deliberately refuses to finish with a tidy accounting diagram showing which soul occupies which body.
The epilogue instead introduces an unnamed young woman in the company of Camilla Hect, opening another identity mystery that becomes central to Nona the Ninth. If you finish Harrow thinking, "I now understand why the book was lying to me, but I am still not entirely sure where everyone ended up," that is roughly the intended position. The original puzzle has been solved; a new one has replaced it.
Why Harrow the Ninth Has to Contradict Gideon the Ninth
The cleverest part of the novel is that it does not simply tell us Harrow has altered her memory. It forces the reader to experience the consequences.
Anyone coming directly from Gideon the Ninth possesses information Harrow no longer possesses. We know Gideon existed. We know she went to Canaan House. We know roughly what happened there. When Harrow the Ninth presents another version of those events, we therefore occupy a peculiar position: we know the narrative is wrong before we have any mechanism for explaining why.
That puts the reader somewhere close to Harrow herself. Her world functions well enough to be inhabited, but badly enough to feel unstable. Names refuse to fit. History contains the wrong people. The past keeps pushing against the story constructed to suppress it. Even the narration knows more than Harrow does.
When the explanation finally arrives, the novel has revealed more than a hidden plot fact. Its entire form turns out to have been organised around Harrow's attempt not to know one particular person. The altered names, impossible history, shifting perspectives and false Canaan House are different expressions of the same absence.
That is why Harrow the Ninth can feel almost hostile on a first read and remarkably precise in retrospect. The book appears to contradict Gideon the Ninth because Harrow has contradicted it inside herself.
She has rebuilt memory, language and even her own nervous system around the absence of one person.
The problem is that Gideon never actually left.
Comments
Post a Comment